Daniel Struve, the editor-in-chief of the YMCA-Press publishing house, and a member of the editorial board of the magazines "Vestnik RHD" and "Messager Orthodoxe" answered questions on the Credo.press website.

“A Boycott of the September 7th Extraordinary General Assembly of the Archdiocese seems unlikely.”
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Vkontakte
  • Messanger
  • Telegram
  • WhatsApp
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest

Credo. Press: Is it true that some of the clergy and lay people of the Archdiocese of Russian Churches in Western Europe are opposed to Archbishop Jean Renneteau’s [Archbishop John of Charioupolis] decision to convene an extraordinary general assembly on September 7th? What is the probability of it being boycotted?

Daniel Struve: I am not aware of the existence of such opposition nor of its reasons. The decision to convene an Extraordinary General Assembly on September 7 was made following the pastoral assembly held on May 9, as announced on the Archbishop’s website. According to the statutes, convening the Extraordinary General Assembly is a prerogative of the archbishop.

No doubt clergy members and lay people support procrastination. But inaction cannot be a response to the challenge facing the Archdiocese today, and it seems to me that everyone is beginning to realize it. A boycott of the assembly seems unlikely. In any case, it would mean a break in the unity of the diocese gathered around the bishop, that is to say, the end of the Archdiocese.

– Archbishop John participated in negotiations with hierarchs of the Russian Church in Vienna on June 21. Do you consider this was justified, especially as it was done without informing two members of the commission created by the general assembly of the Archdiocese to resolve the question of their canonical status, and to conduct such negotiations?

– D.S.: This is a purely internal matter of the Archdiocese. I see no reason or interest in making it a subject of public discussion, except to destabilize the situation. Those interested in the internal organization of the Archdiocese can find out about its statutes on the official website.

– Is it true that a conflict occurred during the June 28th meeting of the diocesan council, after which Archbishop John left the meeting? And if so, what is the cause of this conflict?

– D.S.: Not being a member of the diocesan council, I cannot know nor comment on what happens during non-public sessions of this council. This is a news item published by Credo.ru based on information obtained from anonymous sources, which indicates a conflict between board members. This is an internal affair of the Archdiocese which has its own bodies of administration and control. I do not see the need to make it a subject of public discussion at this stage.

– You claim that Credo.ru published false information about Bishop Savva Tutunov serving as a consultant to Archbishop John in drafting the July 5 documents (convening the General Assembly on September 7). How do you know about this, and how do you know who was in charge of the technical work in preparing these documents?

– D.S.: I do not claim knowing exactly who was in charge of the technical aspect of the preparation of the documents, but the information you published seems to me perfectly far-fetched. The official documents of the Archdiocese are written in French and then translated into Russian. The style of the translations varies according to the translator. There is no material for speculation here.

– How do you personally see the future of the Archdiocese, given the strong will of a significant part of its clergy and laity not to be canonically attached to the Moscow Patriarchate?

– D.S.: The decision taken by the Constantinople Patriarchate at the end of last year to abolish the Archdiocese constitutes a threat to the very existence of our diocese. Only the unexpected refusal of Archbishop John to submit to the decision of the Patriarch and its Synod still allows us to speak of the Archdiocese in the present or even in the future tense, and not in the past tense.

We have to make a difficult choice. I see only three possible scenarios: to put an end to our existence and to melt into Greek metropolitanates, as required by Patriarch Bartholomew; to try to prolong the existence of the Archdiocese within the Moscow Patriarchate; or not to decide anything and let the Archdiocese fall apart.

At the beginning of the discussion, other possible outcomes were mentioned, but they remained at the stage of simple conversations. However, some parishes have already left the Archdiocese and the danger of division increases with time.

Today, the task of all who hold the future of the Archdiocese in their hands is first and foremost to arrive at an accurate understanding of the situation, and to make the difficult choice that best serves to preserve ecclesial unity and the Orthodox testimony in Western Europe.

We all readily talk about “conciliarity”, but reaching consensus from differing positions is not an easy task. Conciliarity does not remove the hierarchical principle in the organization of the Church. In the difficult decisions to be made by the Archdiocese, a key role will belong, on the one hand, to Archbishop John, the guarantor of the unity of the diocese, and on the other hand, to the representatives of the parishes, for whom the Archdiocese is not a view of the mind or an idea, but the life and concrete reality of the Church.

Personally, I am in favor of preserving the diocesan structure of the Archdiocese, which means leaving the jurisdiction of the Constantinople  Patriarchate and joining the Moscow Patriarchate. We simply have no other solution if we want to keep the diocese. If this decision does not get enough support, I prefer a peaceful and organized dissolution of the Diocesan Union, to an uncontrolled collapse and the conflicts that would ensue.

Interview with Alexander Soldatov, translated in French from the Russian for Orthodoxie.com

Source in Russian

Orthodoxie.com Newsletter

Don't miss out on important news and updates. Subscribe to our free bi-weekly newsletter.

Divider

Popular Posts

La lettre du patriarche de Jérusalem au sujet de la réunion d’Amman 168961

Le site internet grec Ethnos.gr a mis en ligne la lettre d’invitation que le patriarche de Jérusalem a envoyée à tous les primats orthodoxes pour l...

L’enregistrement d’un CD du chœur d’hommes “Chantres orthodoxes russes... 168952

Un appel aux dons a été lancé pour permettre l’enregistrement d’un CD du chœur d’hommes “Chantres orthodoxes russes” ...

Un entretien avec Bertrand Vergely 168948

Ci-dessous : la vidéo d’un entretien avec Bertrand Vergely, en dialogue avec l’éditeur et auteur François Huguenin, diffusé il y a quel...

“Le monachisme dans le monde byzantin et en Europe médiévale (II)” 168945

Ci-dessous : le podcast audio de l’émission Orthodoxie sur France-Culture du 16 février consacrée au « Monachisme dans le monde byzantin et en...

L’Église d’Albanie a dépensé près de 11 millions de dollars pour restaurer 63 églises depuis 1991 168941

Malgré la crise financière, l’Église orthodoxe d’Albanie a consacré beaucoup de moyens à la restauration de ses églises en ruine depuis la pe...

Metropolitan Emmanuel of France in Saudi Arabia 168934

Metropolitan Emmanuel of France traveled to Riyadh, at the invitation of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, in order to chair the Board of Directors of t...

Mgr Emmanuel en Arabie saoudite 168923

Mgr Emmanuel, métropolite de France, s’est rendu à Riyad, à l’invitation du Royaume d’Arabie saoudite, afin de présider le consei...

Conférence : “L’antique liturgie du rite des Gaules” par Natalie Depraz, le 29 ... 168918

Samedi 29 février à 15h dans la paroisse Saint-Séraphin de Sarov à Paris (91 rue Lecourbe, 15e), la philosophe Natalie Depraz, professeure à l̵...

Mgr Emmanuel a ordonné un nouveau prêtre du monastère de Xénophon 168903

Le week-end dernier, Mgr Emmanuel, métropolite de France, s’est rendu au monastère de Xénophon au Mont Athos, avec la bénédiction du patriarche œcu...

Le patriarche Élie de Géorgie ne participera pas à la réunion des primats en Jordanie 168893

Le patriarche de Géorgie a décliné l’invitation du patriarche de Jérusalem de participer à la réunion des primats orthodoxes à Amman. Nous publions...

Le métropolite Hilarion de Volokolamsk est en visite à Belgrade 168881

Le métropolite Hilarion, président du département des relations extérieures du Patriarcat de Moscou, a été accueilli aujourd’hui à l’aé...

Métropolite Épiphane : « C’est le privilège du patriarche œcuménique Bartholomée d’accorder l’aut... 168874

Métropolite Épiphane : « L’État russe fait tout pour empêcher notre évolution ». « Je me suis entretenu avec Pompeo ; en effet, l’aide de nos parte...